PickaSi
AI video tools, tested by actually running them.
Standings · October 2026
Sprint A — Generative Shootout · 6 briefs · 3 tools
PROVISIONAL

AI Video Generators — Standings

Same prompt, word for word, in every tool · Runs logged Oct 23, 2026
1LEADER
9:16KlingAI 4.0

Kling 4.0

Standard plan

Best story fidelity at the lowest cost — if the watermark is acceptable on your channel.

4.36
/ 5 · weighted score
$9.54per finished min · $12.00 at renewal
6 briefs0 retries ~8 min avg wall-clockTrue vertical 1080×1920 Watermark bottom-right — frame-verified
2
9:16No watermark

Veo 3.1 Quality

via Flow · Google AI Pro

The clean export for commercial work — best faces, zero garbled text. Just budget for the queue.

3.43
/ 5 · weighted score
$15.00per finished min
6 briefs0 retries ~15 min avg · queue ran ~9–30 minTrue vertical Zero garbled text across the battery
3
16:9

Runway Gen-4.5

Standard plan · text-to-video

Fast and competent — but text-to-video can't do vertical. Enter via image-to-video instead.

2.86
/ 5 · weighted score
$17.28per finished min — a landscape minute
6 briefs0 retries ~10 min avg · fastest run ~3.5 min Text-to-video locked 1280×720 · 9:16 only via Gen-4 Turbo image-to-video

How to read this

Scores are weighted over the three of six protocol dimensions with logged evidence — output quality, cost, speed (70% of protocol weight, renormalized), so this ranking is provisional. Languages, rights/terms and editing control are not scored yet: we publish no score without a test log behind it. One flip to watch: if Kling's Standard tier turns out to have no watermark-removal path, the commercial ranking changes — Veo's clean export is worth more than Kling's price gap for client work.

Sprint B — Free-Tier Avatar & Voice

Same frozen script · $0 plans · outcome only
1
ElevenLabs Free tier
Finished clean73-second audio take of the full script
2
Synthesia Free tier
Finished — watermarked75-second 1080p video, watermark on the export
3
HeyGen Free tier
Hit the wallFree tier caps video at 1 minute; the script runs ~78 seconds — never started